Rare Earth Stocks: The Truce That Isn't a Truce
Recent headlines celebrating a U.S.-China trade truce have lulled the market into a false sense of security, triggering a sharp sell-off in domestic rare earth stocks. But behind the headlines, a more strategic and confrontational reality is emerging.
Beijing is now crafting a validated end-user (VEU) system, a surgical tool designed to maintain the flow of rare earths to approved, purely civilian American companies while explicitly blocking access for the U.S. military and its vast network of contractors.
This is not a de-escalation; it is a declaration of a new, more targeted front in the global tech and defense race. This policy shift makes the development of domestic producers, such as MP Materials (NYSE: MP) and USA Rare Earth (NASDAQ: USAR), not only strategically important but absolutely mission-critical.
China Sharpens Its Weapon, Russia Joins the Fray
The pressure to build a secure U.S. supply chain is now coming from two global rivals, transforming the strategic landscape and solidifying the long-term investment case for domestic producers.
First, China has sharpened its export control weapons. The VEU plan is a sophisticated escalation that weaponizes its supply chain dominance by creating a potential red list for defense-related firms. This sows uncertainty for any U.S. company with dual-use applications in sectors like aerospace and automotive.
The targeted approach is designed to inflict maximum pain on America's national security apparatus while minimizing collateral damage to the broader commercial relationship, making it a more sustainable and dangerous long-term policy.
Second, while China refines its export tools, Russia is now moving to build its own. President Vladimir Putin's recent directive to create a national strategy roadmap for rare earth extraction signals a long-term strategic pivot. This raises the prospect of a coordinated China-Russia bloc in critical minerals, which would further consolidate supply away from the West.
This development elevates the U.S. domestic supply chain initiative from an important industrial policy to an urgent, non-negotiable national security mission. The investment case is no longer a speculative hedge on a trade war; it is now a fundamental bet on a government-mandated build-out of a specific, defense-oriented supply chain.
De-Risked and Ready to Deliver
China's VEU plan makes the U.S. government's recent multi-billion-dollar investments in its domestic rare earth sector look not just strategic, but prescient. Washington is building a resilient ecosystem designed to withstand this exact threat, with MP Materials and USA Rare Earth as its cornerstones.
- MP Materials: America's Designated Prime Contractor. China's strategy to cut off the U.S. military directly elevates the importance of MP. Its contracts with the Department of Defense are now more critical than ever. The 10-year price floor, which began on Oct. 1, is a direct countermeasure, guaranteeing revenue stability for the very products China seeks to restrict. MP Materials’ recent third-quarter 2025 earnings report showed record production of 721 metric tons of high-value NdPr, demonstrating its ability to meet this secure demand with sufficient feedstock. With a $1.94 billion cash hoard, it has the firepower to accelerate its build-out to meet any new defense-related demand surges.
- USA Rare Earth: The Strategic Second Source. In a world of targeted supply chain attacks, redundancy is key. USAR's recent acquisition of UK-based Less Common Metals (LCM) is a strategic masterstroke, providing immediate, non-Chinese expertise in the specialized metals and alloys needed for defense-grade magnets. This move, combined with a massive post-Q3 cash position of over $400 million, positions USAR as the clear choice to become America's critical second source, dramatically increasing its chances of securing lucrative DoD contracts as it approaches its Q1 2026 commissioning.
The Market's Miscalculation: A Powder Keg of Opportunity
The market sold off on the simplistic truce headline, creating a stark valuation disconnect. Analyst consensus remains a Moderate Buy on both companies, and the price drops have made the upside to their average price targets even more compelling.
As of Nov. 11, the consensus price target implies a potential upside of over 26% for MP Materials and over 48% for USA Rare Earth.
Adding a powerful technical dynamic is the high level of short interest against the sector, standing at a compelling 17.89% for MP and 14.45% for USAR. This extreme pessimism creates a coiled spring scenario. Any sudden geopolitical escalation, such as a formal announcement of China's VEU list or a new U.S. defense contract, could instantly invalidate the bearish thesis, forcing short-sellers to buy back shares en masse.
This rush of forced buying could trigger an explosive rebound. The race for rare earth supremacy is accelerating. For investors with a long-term horizon, the market's current fear may have just put a strategically vital sector on sale.
Learn more about MP
